I found an interesting article from FastCompany on why many people dislike and disrespect human resources. You can read it here. Whether you agree with the article or not, I think it is fair to say that HR has a bad reputation in many circles, and that there is work to be done in the industry.
I freely admit that I think about the HR function with mixed feelings. What have I learned about HR since I left HR?
1) In retrospect, I wasn't as good as I thought I was. Yes, I was service oriented and hard working. Yes, I had good relationships with my customers and helped them in tangible ways. I was a strong coach and a good project manager. But there was so much that I didn't know too. I was completely out of the loop strategically, woefully ignorant on the subject of metrics and creating measurable improvement, uneducated on change management, and a financial dunce.
Even as a "very good" HR manager, I lacked business sense and many necessary skills. Even more importantly, I was completely unaware that I lacked these skills, or why they were important.
2) We made poor use of staff dollars trying to get jumbled job tasks to "fit" a finite supply of people. Job duties in HR tend to splinter in all but the biggest companies. You need someone to run reports, and someone to file, and someone to administer a particular program, and someone to.... and so you squish all these duties under different job roles.
As a business owner, tasks don't interest me. I'm interested in results. So I wish I had hired people to deliver certain results, instead of hiring people to do a laundry list of tasks. Who cares about filing? Get a temp to do it. Who cares about resumes? Hire someone to increase staff quality and retention. That is what you measure.
HR people are trained in job analysis, looking at tasks and duties, and so forth. I spent too much time looking at task and process, not enough time on outcomes.
3) We operated in the dark.
Tasks or projects would come down from our leadership, and we would execute, somewhat blind to why this or that initiative was most important. Because of this, we needed more direction from our leaders than we should have, and we were often lagging the organizational trends. We tended to "manage by crisis" or "manage by complaints" instead of leading the charge.
HR people tend to be service or support oriented, which can lead to a lot of nice people trying to help you fight fires instead of build fireproof structures. I didn't have the skills at the time to see where the fire was coming from, I just kept the water coming.
A New Approach to HR
I'm not sure if I would work in HR again, but if I did, I would do some things differently.
1. I would educate myself and my staff on company financials and financial management.
2. I would operate the department like a business, ensuring that each program and function either added to revenue, controlled costs, or lowered risk in tangible ways that were aligned with company values and ethics.
3. I would build the HR function on a set of metrics aligned with strategic goals, and track progress openly with the company. What is our trend in turnover? Cost per hire? Employee satisfaction? Internal promotions?
4. I would manage less towards duties, and more towards outcomes.
5. I would outsource any tasks that didn't add value and could be done reliably at a lower cost by a vendor or partner.
6. I would offer an aggressive development program for my team in business skills, consulting approach, and operational realities.
7. I would hire more people with operational experience to work in HR.
What are your thoughts on the HR function?